Nissan's Chairman's Innovation Award had surfaced a genuinely bold concept: cars that could change color using e-ink technology. John Ferguson's idea represented exactly the kind of breakthrough thinking the award was designed to encourage.
Winning an innovation award creates momentum but not validation. The organization had no systematic way to test whether bold concepts were viable businesses or expensive fantasies. Resources risked being allocated based on excitement rather than evidence.
We treated the idea as a 'stack of hypotheses' hiding the project's real risks. Rather than building toward a distant launch, we designed experiments to surface the truth quickly and cheaply.
The Hypothesis-Driven Kill Protocol: Identify the two critical risks (technical feasibility and customer desirability). Test technical feasibility by contacting e-ink technology providers. Validate market demand through street interviews in London and a Facebook video campaign measuring real-world interest.
Data from the Facebook campaign was conclusive: there wasn't strong market demand for the feature. The project was intentionally killed—a 'positive failure' that saved Nissan millions in development costs.
The methodology is now used for all Chairman's Innovation Award winners. The organization has internalized that 'positive failure' is a success, and hypothesis-driven validation has become the standard approach for evaluating breakthrough concepts.
"I very quickly saw the benefit of the approach. The coaches gave me deadlines, things to deliver, which I really needed."
John Ferguson
Technical Architect, Nissan Europe
This engagement took weeks, not months. If your team is dealing with the same kind of problem, a 30-minute conversation will tell us whether we can help.
Get started →
Client: Groupe Renault
Renault had built a global automotive empire through engineering excellence and manufacturing discipline. Their ability to coordinate complex cross-functional projects was world-class.
Client: Schneider Electric
Schneider Electric excelled at operating their current business model—industrializing and distributing goods across the world. Their engineering and operational capabilities were industry-leading.
